5W20 Oil Comparison

HP Junkies Oil Comparison · updated November 22, 2026

Which 5W-20 actually protects your Ford, Honda, Hyundai or Chrysler engine best? We pulled the published data sheets for 24 popular 5W-20 oils and lined them up side by side, split into full synthetics and synthetic blends so every oil only competes against its own kind.

Oil Definition page | 0W20 | 5W20 | 5W30 | 10W30

New to these charts? Read How to read our oil charts for what every column means and how scoring works.

How to read these charts

  • Every number comes from the oil maker's own data sheet (PDS/TDS) or official product page. Nothing is estimated. Sources for every oil are listed at the bottom of the page.
  • n/p = not published. The maker doesn't list that value, so we leave it blank and it does not count for or against the oil.
  • Scoring: in each scored column, oils are ranked only against the other oils in their group that publish that value. The best gets 3 points, the worst gets 0, and everything in between is spaced evenly by rank (ties share the better rank). The score badge shows points earned out of the points possible for the columns that oil publishes, so an oil isn't punished for a blank, but it can't win a column it doesn't publish either. A column only one oil in the group publishes isn't scored.
  • Green cells are the column winner within that group. Oils that publish fewer than 3 scored values are listed but not ranked. Tap or click any column header to sort (tap again to reverse); n/p values always go to the bottom.
  • Grey "PMCC" flash points were measured with the closed-cup method (ASTM D93), which reads lower than the open-cup method (ASTM D92) most makers use, so they're shown but not scored. Values published only as a limit (like "≤ -36" or "< 15%") are shown but not scored.
  • KV100, approvals and price are there to help you choose, but they are not part of the score.

Top picks at a glance

Can't always find your first choice on the shelf? Here are a clear 1st, 2nd and 3rd pick in each group, ranked by score. Always confirm the approval your owner's manual or tuner asks for before you buy.

Full Synthetic (overall)

  1. 1stAMSOIL Signature Series 5W-20 (ALM) 13.3/18 pts
    Best or tied-best in its group for pour point; carries API SQ and dexos1 Gen3 (LSPI-tested); scored on 6 of 6 columns.
  2. 2ndRed Line 5W-20 Motor Oil 8.1/12 pts
    Best or tied-best in its group for NOACK and HTHS; its maker lists API specs as met or recommended, but it is not API licensed; scored on 4 of 6 columns.
  3. 3rdRoyal Purple HPS 5W-20 9.4/15 pts
    Best or tied-best in its group for viscosity index; not API SP/SQ licensed, so best suited to modified or out-of-warranty engines; scored on 5 of 6 columns.

Full Synthetic (API SP/SQ licensed only)

  1. 1stAMSOIL Signature Series 5W-20 (ALM) 13.3/18 pts
    Best or tied-best in its group for pour point; carries API SQ and dexos1 Gen3 (LSPI-tested); scored on 6 of 6 columns.
  2. 2ndAMSOIL OE 5W-20 (OEM) 10.6/18 pts
    No column wins; strongest showing is HTHS; carries API SQ and dexos1 Gen3 (LSPI-tested); scored on 6 of 6 columns.
  3. 3rdAMSOIL 100% Synthetic High-Mileage 5W-20 (HM520) 10.3/18 pts
    No column wins; strongest showing is HTHS; carries API SQ and dexos1 Gen3 (LSPI-tested); scored on 6 of 6 columns.

Synthetic Blend 5W-20

  1. 1stValvoline Daily Protection 5W-20 (synthetic blend) 6/9 pts
    Best or tied-best in its group for HTHS and TBN; API SQ licensed; scored on 3 of 6 columns.
  2. 2ndPetro-Canada Supreme 5W-20 (synthetic blend) 9/15 pts
    Best or tied-best in its group for viscosity index, pour point and HTHS; API SP licensed; scored on 5 of 6 columns.
  3. Not enough published data to rank a 3rd pick. See the note under the table.

Which oil for your build?

Daily drivers that call for 5W-20 (Ford, Honda, Hyundai/Kia, Chrysler)

5W-20 was the factory fill for millions of 2000s and 2010s Ford Modular and Duratec, Honda, Hyundai/Kia and Chrysler engines. Stick with an API SQ/SP and ILSAC GF-7A/GF-6A licensed oil, and the Ford WSS-M2C945 / M2C960 / M2C970 spec if your manual lists it. Among licensed oils, favour low NOACK (less oil burned off) and a strong HTHS for the grade.

Turbo direct injection (EcoBoost and similar)

Small turbocharged DI engines are prone to low-speed pre-ignition (LSPI), which can crack pistons and break ring lands. API SQ/SP and GF-7A/GF-6A oils have all passed an LSPI engine test, so buy a licensed oil. Some tuners recommend a heavier grade such as 5W-30 for track use, towing or big tunes; only move up a grade when your owner's manual or your tuner says so.

High mileage and older engines

Seal conditioners in high-mileage oils can help with small leaks and oil consumption. Higher TBN gives more acid-fighting reserve for long intervals. A high-zinc oil like Royal Purple HPS adds wear protection for flat-tappet or modified engines, but it is not API licensed, so keep it for out-of-warranty cars.

E85 / flex fuel and cold climates

Ethanol washes past the rings into the oil (fuel dilution) and brings moisture and acids with it, which thins a 5W-20. Look for higher TBN, check the oil level often and shorten your change interval. Petro-Canada states its Supreme oils suit fuel up to E85. In very cold climates a low pour point helps cold-start flow.

Full Synthetic 5W-20

Full Synthetic 5W-20 sorted by score · scroll sideways on mobile
OilKV100cSt, infoViscosity IndexhigherFlash Point°C, higherPour Point°C, lowerNOACK% loss, lowerHTHScP, higherTBNhigherScorepts / possibleKey approvalsPrice / qtUSD
AMSOIL Signature Series 5W-20 (ALM)9.1157232-515.62.710.413.3/18API SQGF-7Adexos1 Gen3FordChrysler–
Red Line 5W-20 Motor Oil9148n/p-4543.1n/p8.1/12API SNFordChrysler–
Royal Purple HPS 5W-208.6173216-48n/p2.79.79.4/15No API licence listed–
AMSOIL OE 5W-20 (OEM)8.5156232-467.32.8810.6/18API SQGF-7Adexos1 Gen3FordChrysler–
AMSOIL 100% Synthetic High-Mileage 5W-20 (HM520)8.8158228-427.72.81010.3/18API SQGF-7Adexos1 Gen3FordChrysler–
AMSOIL Extended-Life (XL) 5W-20 (XLM)8.7155226-428.42.910.79.4/18API SQGF-7Adexos1 Gen3FordChrysler–
Royal Purple High Performance 5W-208.2156226-42n/p2.7n/p5.5/12API SQGF-7A–
Petro-Canada Supreme Synthetic 5W-208.2160234-4210.22.688.1/18API SPGF-6Adexos1 Gen3Ford–
Royal Purple HMX High Mileage 5W-208.4158221-45n/p2.68.96.5/15API SPFordChrysler–
Kendall GT-1 Max Full Synthetic 5W-20 (LiquiTek)8.7165229-41n/p2.675.8/15API SPGF-6AFordChrysler–
Castrol EDGE 5W-208.4150200PMCC-42n/pn/pn/p1.9/6not rankedAPI SQGF-7AFordChrysler–
Mobil 1 Advanced Clean 5W-20 (standard Mobil 1)8.6n/p229-39n/pn/pn/p1.9/6not rankedAPI SQGF-7AFordChrysler–
Mobil 1 Extended Performance 5W-208.8n/p240-42n/pn/pn/p4.7/6not rankedAPI SQGF-7AFordChrysler–
Mobil 1 High Mileage 5W-208.3n/p233-36n/pn/pn/p2.2/6not rankedAPI SQGF-7AFordChrysler–
Mobil Super Synthetic 5W-208.32n/p237-39n/pn/pn/p3.1/6not rankedAPI SQGF-7AFordChrysler–
Pennzoil Platinum 5W-208.6167205PMCC-48n/pn/pn/p5.6/6not rankedAPI SPGF-6Adexos1 Gen2FordChrysler–
Pennzoil Ultra Platinum 5W-208.8164207PMCC-48n/pn/pn/p5.2/6not rankedAPI SQGF-7AFordChrysler–
Valvoline Advanced Protection Full Synthetic 5W-208156n/p≤ -36limit< 15limit2.6n/p2.3/6not rankedAPI SQGF-7AFordChrysler–
Valvoline Extended Protection Full Synthetic 5W-208.3162n/p≤ -36limit< 15limit2.6n/p3.3/6not rankedAPI SQGF-7AFordChrysler–
Valvoline Restore and Protect Full Synthetic 5W-208.4153n/p≤ -36limit< 15limitn/pn/p0.4/3not rankedAPI SQGF-7AFord–

NOACK volatility (lower is better)

Red Line4%
AMSOIL Signature Series5.6%
AMSOIL OE7.3%
AMSOIL 100% Synthetic High-Mileage7.7%
AMSOIL Extended-Life (XL)8.4%
Petro-Canada Supreme Synthetic10.2%

HTHS viscosity @ 150°C (higher is better)

Red Line3.1 cP
AMSOIL Extended-Life (XL)2.9 cP
AMSOIL OE2.8 cP
AMSOIL 100% Synthetic High-Mileage2.8 cP
AMSOIL Signature Series2.7 cP
Royal Purple High Performance2.7 cP
Royal Purple HPS2.7 cP
Valvoline Extended Protection Full Synthetic2.6 cP
Valvoline Advanced Protection Full Synthetic2.6 cP
Royal Purple HMX High Mileage2.6 cP
Kendall GT-1 Max Full Synthetic2.6 cP
Petro-Canada Supreme Synthetic2.6 cP
Notes on these oils
  • Mobil 1 Advanced Clean 5W-20 (standard Mobil 1): Current US name for the standard Mobil 1 line. Mobil US PDS lists only density, flash point, KV and pour point.
  • Mobil 1 Extended Performance 5W-20: Mobil US PDS lists only density, flash point, KV and pour point.
  • Castrol EDGE 5W-20: Castrol publishes flash point by PMCC (ASTM D93), which reads lower than open-cup (D92), so it is shown but not scored.
  • Pennzoil Ultra Platinum 5W-20: Flash point published by PMCC (ASTM D93) only, so not scored. The TDS does not list NOACK, HTHS or TBN.
  • Pennzoil Platinum 5W-20: Newest Pennzoil Platinum 5W-20 sheet with typical values we could find is the API SP version; bottles now on shelves may be API SQ. Flash point by PMCC (ASTM D93), not scored.
  • Valvoline Extended Protection Full Synthetic 5W-20: Pour point and NOACK published only as limits, so not scored.
  • Valvoline Advanced Protection Full Synthetic 5W-20: Pour point and NOACK published only as limits, so not scored.
  • Valvoline Restore and Protect Full Synthetic 5W-20: Only VI is published as a scored typical value, so it is not ranked.
  • Royal Purple HMX High Mileage 5W-20: Royal Purple says HMX meets API SP performance but it is not API licensed.
  • Royal Purple HPS 5W-20: High-zinc street performance oil. Not API licensed, so it drops out of the licensed-only picks.
  • Red Line 5W-20 Motor Oil: Ester/PAO oil. Red Line lists these specs as 'recommended for', not licensed. No flash point or TBN published. HTHS by ASTM D4741. The PDF sheet lists NOACK 4%; Red Line's product web page lists 8%. We show the PDF value.
  • Kendall GT-1 Max Full Synthetic 5W-20 (LiquiTek): Phosphorus 0.077 wt% and zinc 0.085 wt% as published (= 770 / 850 ppm).
  • Petro-Canada Supreme Synthetic 5W-20: Pour point by ASTM D5950. Phosphorus 0.07 mass% (= 700 ppm). PDS states suitability for fuels up to E85.

Synthetic Blend 5W-20

Synthetic blends mix conventional and synthetic base oils. They are ranked only against each other.

Synthetic Blend 5W-20 sorted by score · scroll sideways on mobile
OilKV100cSt, infoViscosity IndexhigherFlash Point°C, higherPour Point°C, lowerNOACK% loss, lowerHTHScP, higherTBNhigherScorepts / possibleKey approvalsPrice / qtUSD
Valvoline Daily Protection 5W-20 (synthetic blend)8.5147n/p≤ -39limit< 15limit2.67.16/9API SQGF-7AFordChrysler–
Petro-Canada Supreme 5W-20 (synthetic blend)8.6156222-4512.32.679/15API SPGF-6AFord–
Mobil Super 5W-20 (synthetic blend)8.91n/p231-45n/pn/pn/p6/6not rankedAPI SQGF-7AFord–
AMSOIL Synthetic-Blend 5W-20 (SB520)n/p> 120limit> 200limit-44< 12.5limit> 2.6limit> 6limit0/3not rankedAPI SQGF-7Adexos1 Gen3FordChrysler–

HTHS viscosity @ 150°C (higher is better)

Valvoline Daily Protection2.6 cP
Petro-Canada Supreme2.6 cP
Notes on these oils
  • AMSOIL Synthetic-Blend 5W-20 (SB520): The current bulletin publishes KV100 only as a 6.9-9.3 cSt range, and VI, flash point, NOACK, HTHS and TBN only as limits, so those values are shown but not scored. Pour point is a typical value and is scored.
  • Mobil Super 5W-20 (synthetic blend): Mobil describes the Mobil Super series as synthetic blend oils. Mobil US PDS lists only density, flash point, KV and pour point.
  • Valvoline Daily Protection 5W-20 (synthetic blend): Pour point and NOACK published only as limits, so not scored.
  • Petro-Canada Supreme 5W-20 (synthetic blend): Petro-Canada describes Supreme as a blend of Group II and Group III synthetic base oils. Pour point by ASTM D5950. Phosphorus 0.08 % wt (= 800 ppm).

No Conventional table: we found no conventional 5W-20 whose maker publishes a current data sheet with typical values, so that group is left out for this grade.

Phosphorus and zinc (ZDDP)

Shown for information only, not scored. Most makers don't publish these numbers; blanks mean not published, not zero.

Phosphorus and zinc (info only, where the data sheet publishes it)
OilPhosphorus ppmZinc ppm
Valvoline Extended Protection Full Synthetic 5W-20800940
Valvoline Advanced Protection Full Synthetic 5W-20780900
Valvoline Restore and Protect Full Synthetic 5W-20650720
Kendall GT-1 Max Full Synthetic 5W-20 (LiquiTek)770850
Petro-Canada Supreme Synthetic 5W-20700n/p
Valvoline Daily Protection 5W-20 (synthetic blend)660710
Petro-Canada Supreme 5W-20 (synthetic blend)800n/p

Quick key

  • Higher is better: Viscosity Index, Flash Point, HTHS, TBN.
  • Lower is better: NOACK volatility, Pour Point.
  • Info only (not scored): KV100, phosphorus/zinc, approvals, price.
  • Want to know what each category means and why it matters for heads/cam, boost and E85 builds? Read How to Read Our Oil Charts.

Notes and data sources

Values are the makers' published "typical" numbers, not guaranteed specifications, and makers change formulas over time. Where a brand's newest data sheet is older than its current bottle (for example an API SP sheet for an oil now sold as API SQ), we used the newest sheet with typical values we could find and noted it. Prices were not checked for this page yet (checked November 22, 2026), so the price column shows dashes. Oil names that are links go to the product on Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, HP Junkies earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Data sources for every oil (checked November 22, 2026)
  • AMSOIL Signature Series 5W-20 (ALM) – data sheet (Data Bulletin G2880, 11/26)
  • AMSOIL Extended-Life (XL) 5W-20 (XLM) – data sheet (Data Bulletin G1404, 7/26)
  • AMSOIL OE 5W-20 (OEM) – data sheet (Data Bulletin G3404, 11/26)
  • AMSOIL 100% Synthetic High-Mileage 5W-20 (HM520) – data sheet (Data Bulletin G3831, 12/25)
  • Mobil 1 Advanced Clean 5W-20 (standard Mobil 1) – data sheet (US PDS, dated 09-2026)
  • Mobil 1 Extended Performance 5W-20 – data sheet (US PDS, dated 09-2026)
  • Mobil 1 High Mileage 5W-20 – data sheet (US PDS)
  • Mobil Super Synthetic 5W-20 – data sheet (US PDS, dated 09-2026)
  • Castrol EDGE 5W-20 – data sheet (Castrol US PDS dated 30 Sep 2024, API SQ / GF-7 version, hosted by NAPA)
  • Pennzoil Ultra Platinum 5W-20 – data sheet (SOPUS TDS v2.7, 08.10.2026)
  • Pennzoil Platinum 5W-20 – data sheet (SOPUS TDS v2.0, 05.14.2020, hosted by distributor)
  • Valvoline Extended Protection Full Synthetic 5W-20 – data sheet (US PI sheet, effective 10/31/2025)
  • Valvoline Advanced Protection Full Synthetic 5W-20 – data sheet (US PI sheet, effective 3/11/2026)
  • Valvoline Restore and Protect Full Synthetic 5W-20 – data sheet (US PI sheet, effective 8/19/2025)
  • Royal Purple High Performance 5W-20 – data sheet (Royal Purple PDS, 29 Apr 2025)
  • Royal Purple HMX High Mileage 5W-20 – data sheet (Royal Purple PDS, 12 Aug 2024)
  • Royal Purple HPS 5W-20 – data sheet (PDS dated 7/6/2021)
  • Red Line 5W-20 Motor Oil – data sheet (Red Line product info sheet, 06.05.23)
  • Kendall GT-1 Max Full Synthetic 5W-20 (LiquiTek) – data sheet (Kendall PDS dated 07-20-2022)
  • Petro-Canada Supreme Synthetic 5W-20 – data sheet (Petro-Canada Lubricants Tech Data IM-7978E, 2022.06, hosted by distributor)
  • AMSOIL Synthetic-Blend 5W-20 (SB520) – data sheet (Data Bulletin G3882, 4/26)
  • Mobil Super 5W-20 (synthetic blend) – data sheet (US PDS, dated 09-2026)
  • Valvoline Daily Protection 5W-20 (synthetic blend) – data sheet (US PI sheet, effective 1/7/2026)
  • Petro-Canada Supreme 5W-20 (synthetic blend) – data sheet (Petro-Canada Lubricants Tech Data IM-7872E, 2020.05, hosted by distributor)

*** Please note that there may be errors in the data from time to time. Should you notice some incorrect information, or would like to see an oil compared that isn't listed above, please tell us by visiting our contact us page and sending us a message.

Oil will almost always spark a debate – if you found the above chart to be useful to you, please share it among your car forums and social groups.

Oil Definition page | 0W20 | 5W20 | 5W30 | 10W30